An AI-photo label is on the way. A managing-agent license waits. We see a decades-old pattern.
The planned rule requiring AI-altered listing photos to carry a disclosure is a good idea. It is also the easy kind of rule: existing authority, no new office, no one's power reduced. Run those questions on measures for condo and co-op owners and, in our reading, a pattern appears. Companion to the $977 Arizona foreclosure and New York's condo-reform record.
On September 16, Mayor Zohran Mamdani posted that "New Yorkers should know whether the apartment they're looking at is real" and that the city is "working to require apartment listings to clearly disclose when images and videos have been generated by AI." The idea is not new. It is one of 23 actions in the Rental Ripoff Report released July 16, after the administration engaged over 2,400 New Yorkers through listening sessions, interactive boards and online testimony. The report says the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection seeks to do this "by using its rulemaking authority under the Consumer Protection Law," then work with StreetEasy, Zillow and others. The report never uses the words condominium or shareholder, and in our reading it has no recommendation addressed to owners of condos or co-ops. That is not an oversight in a tenant report. In our view it is a useful picture of what a government finds easy to do.
Four questions.
Here is our shorthand for why some reforms move quickly. It is an opinion and not a law of politics. Ask four things about a proposal.
- Existing authority. Can an agency do it by rule, with no legislature and no vote to lose?
- No new program. Does it avoid creating an office someone has to run and fund?
- No lost power. Does it leave a board's or a manager's underlying discretion and money where they are?
- A one-sentence headline. Is the harm visible in a screenshot and the fix small enough for a caption?
The AI-listing rule, if adopted as described, answers yes to all four. A disclosure label asks whoever posts a rental listing for a line of text, and "housefishing" is a word people repeat. None of that makes the rule wrong. Condo and co-op buyers see listings too, and A11635 would extend a similar duty to listings for sale. The point is what these questions do to everything else.
Run the questions on measures for owners.
Below are measures affecting owners in the city's 15,108 condo and co-op buildings, alongside what the city and state have recently enacted. The outcome column is the record. The other columns are our reading.
| Measure | Authority | New program or cost | Who loses money or discretion | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AI-altered listing disclosure | DCWP rule, existing law | None described | Those posting rental listings add a label; DCWP says it will work with StreetEasy, Zillow and other listing companies | Announced July 16, 2026; reaffirmed September 16; rule not yet final as far as we found |
| 90-day notice before a condo lien foreclosure (S7413/A3470) | State statute | None | Boards keep the remedy | Passed the Senate 53-0 as A3470; Chapter 433, signed October 16, 2025 |
| Co-op application decision clock (Intro 1120-B) | Council local law, enforced by HPD | Existing agency | Boards keep the decision and gain a deadline | Local Law 58 of 2026, enacted over a mayoral veto |
| Deed-theft statute (S.6577) | State statute | None new | Fraudsters | Chapter 630 of 2023 |
| Managing-agent registration and certification (S.71) | State statute; Secretary of State registry and approved certifying organizations | $50 registration fee, per the bill memo | The occupation. A trade group, CAI, says it amended Utah's licensing law to exempt community association managers; the text we found is narrower | Stayed in committee through nine consecutive sessions |
| Condo and co-op ombudsperson (S7745) | State statute; new program | $6 per unit per year, paid by the corporation or association, per the bill | Boards answer to a forum; associations pay the fee | Referred to committee in 2025 and again in 2026; no vote |
| Rejection-reason disclosure for co-op applicants (Int. 0774-2026) | Council local law | None we saw | Boards lose discretion to stay silent | In committee since March 10, 2026 |
| Reserve fund requirement (S7600 / A8945) | State statute | None to the state; real to buildings | Boards lose budget discretion | S7600 was reported from Senate Judiciary to Finance on May 28, 2025, and referred back to Judiciary on January 7, 2026; no floor vote |
| Minimum arrears before a lien foreclosure (this site's proposal) | State statute | None | Boards and collection counsel lose the remedy below the floor | We found no New York bill |
Read the outcome column against the rest. The enacted measures did not pass every question. Each of them went through a legislature, and Local Law 58 needed a veto override: the record shows "Vetoed by Mayor" on December 31, 2025 and "Overridden by Council" on January 29, 2026. So "no vote to lose" is a test only the AI rule meets. What the enacted measures share, in our reading, is narrower: none creates a new state program, and each leaves a board's underlying power in place. Measures that did not advance mostly do one or both of the opposite. They create a certifying or complaint system, or take a decision or a remedy away from a group that has counsel.
The 90-day foreclosure notice is the clean example. A3470 passed the Senate 53-0. Our reading is that a notice changes when a board may act, not whether. Arizona's floor, a lien foreclosure only after 18 months or $10,000, changes whether. We found no New York bill for one, though we did not search every session.
Decades of the same pattern.
The pattern is not a feature of this administration. Here is how we read New York's answers on condo and co-op governance. We limit this to governance oversight: New York has also given owners things like the partial property tax abatement in RPTL § 467-a, which is a fiscal benefit and a different subject.
- The Condominium Act. Real Property Law Article 9-B gives boards a lien for common charges, the right to foreclose it "in like manner as a mortgage," and the power "to bid in the unit at foreclosure sale." § 339-aa still sets no minimum debt and no minimum delinquency before that power may be used.
- The conversion statute. General Business Law § 352-eeee protects non-purchasing tenants during a conversion. It is a protection for renters at the moment of conversion, and it adds no oversight of the boards that conversion creates.
- 1990. The Court of Appeals decides Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp., 75 N.Y.2d 530. As the court later described it in 40 West 67th Street v. Pullman, the case applied the business judgment rule to a co-op board, so that a court should defer "[s]o long as the board acts for the purposes of the cooperative, within the scope of its authority and in good faith." We found no statute that pairs that deference with a forum for owners other than the courts. See our post on what the rule leaves unregulated.
- 1994 and 1999. CooperatorNews reported at the time that the Manhattan District Attorney's 1994 investigation ended with the conviction of 72 managing agents for taking contractor payoffs, with a restitution fund of over $4 million, and that the DA's investigations chief called it "Round One." The 1999 round indicted 21 corporations and 62 individuals, among them managing agents, superintendents, vendors, board members, architects and engineers. The response was prosecution, case by case, under existing law. Thirty-two years later there is still no license specific to condo and co-op managing agents.
- 2009 to 2026. A managing-agent registration and certification bill, now S.71, goes nine consecutive sessions without passing, staying in committee throughout.
- 2023. Chapter 630 gives prosecutors new tools against deed theft.
- 2025. Chapter 433 adds a 90-day notice before a condo or HOA lien foreclosure. A notice, not a floor.
- 2026. Local Law 58 gives co-op applicants a 45-day decision clock. A clock, not a reason. The Rental Ripoff Report proposes an AI disclosure label. A label, not a license. The 2026 session concludes June 5 with S.71 and S7745 in committee and no floor vote on S7600.
Line up what got done: a tenant protection, prosecutions, a notice, a clock, and a label on the way. Line up what waited: a license, a forum, a reason, a reserve. A floor has not even been proposed in a bill that we found. In our view, the first list is made of things that leave existing power alone. The second would give someone new jurisdiction over, or take a decision from, a group that would rather keep it. We think that record is too long to call a coincidence.
Why a tenant report did not reach owners.
Two facts help explain the gap, and neither is a slight. First, authority. The city can regulate a listing under its Consumer Protection Law. It does license some trades: DOB refers to "NYC-licensed master plumbers, master fire suppression piping contractors, and master electricians." Whether it could license managing agents is a separate question we have not resolved. It cannot amend the Condominium Act or the Business Corporation Law, and much of what owners seek is a state statute, though Local Law 58 shows the Council can act on some of it. Second, constituency. The report covers renters by design. More than 1,500 people attended the hearings and over 850 submitted online testimony because the administration set them up for tenants. We know of no equivalent for owners, and a group that does not testify does not appear in the report that testimony produces.
A11635, introduced by the Committee on Rules at the request of Assembly Member Linda Rosenthal, would require disclosure of digitally altered images in advertising for the sale or lease of real property. It was referred to the Housing Committee on July 29, 2026, and has had no further action.
What would test the pattern on purpose.
The city cannot pass a state license, but in our view there are steps within reach that would put owners in the next report.
- Hold an owner hearing series on the Ripoff model: five boroughs, a published transcript, a numbered report. The tenant hearings exist because someone set a date.
- Build on the registration contacts HPD already publishes as open data, which include agents, so that an owner can search for an agent and the buildings tied to that agent. See our post on the registry.
- Send Albany a memorandum of support for reintroducing S.71 and S7745 in the 2027 legislature, with the mayor's name on it. Free, and on the record. We found no announced sponsor for S.71 in 2027.
- Ask DCWP, which is already working on the listing rule, whether a co-op board's failure to state a reason for rejecting a buyer is a practice it can reach. If the answer is no, say so publicly, so the gap has an owner.
None of these substitutes for a state license, a state ombudsperson, or a statutory foreclosure floor. They are steps that make a mayor's office a place those three get asked for, and they give the next report a reason to use the word condominium.
Bottom line.
The planned AI-listing rule, if adopted as described, is a good one. It is also the easy kind: existing authority, no new office, no one's power reduced, one sentence. In our reading, the measures owners would need are harder for a plain reason. A license, a forum and a reserve rule each create a new check or take a decision away from someone with counsel, and so would a foreclosure floor if anyone filed one. What New York has done in those years is mostly a notice, a clock and prosecutions under existing law, and 72 convictions after 1994 produced no license specific to condo and co-op managing agents by 2026. We do not think a better mayor alone fixes this. Owners who are not in the report would have to make the status quo costlier than the change. Use the letter-to-your-representative tool to ask whether your legislators would back reintroducing S.71, S7745 and S7600 in 2027.
Correction: An earlier version of this article said the Rental Ripoff Report never mentions cooperatives, boards or managing agents (it does; it never uses condominium or shareholder), said everything enacted passed all four tests and that a committee had heard the photo bill, and gave June 18 as the end of the 2026 session (it was June 5). The article was corrected on November 4 and 5, 2026.
Primary sources: Rental Ripoff Report · VIN News on the mayor's post · S7413 · Int. 1120-B / Local Law 58 · S.6577 · S.71 · S7745 · S7600 · Int. 0774-2026 · A11635 · RPL § 339-aa · GBL § 352-eeee · 40 West 67th Street v. Pullman · CooperatorNews (1999) · Ariz. Rev. Stat. § 33-1256
Companion resources: An Arizona HOA took a house over $977 · New York's condo-reform record · S.71, the licensure bill · S7745, the ombudsperson bill · Albany 2026: four reform bills, no vote · Why we built this · Letter to your representative