The co-op group against Local Law 97 is the renamed version of a group that, New York Focus reports, got over $750,000 from a REBNY-run lobbying group. The lobbying rules we read do not require telling owners at a rally.
State lobbying law can reach grassroots campaigns and can require funding-source reports, and this group has a state registration. The bills it backs are City Council bills. The gap we see is narrower than a missing law: such reports go to regulators, not to the shareholder at the rally. Companion to The NYC local-law extraction stack.
Co-ops and Condos United of NY has rallied co-op and condo owners against Local Law 97 fines, including at Southbridge Towers in Lower Manhattan, in a report posted September 8, 2026. Its March 2026 launch announcement called it "a grassroots advocacy group" and did not mention REBNY. New York Focus reported in September that the group is a rebranding of one that received all its funding, over $750,000, from a lobbying group run by the Real Estate Board of New York. Geoffrey Mazel, CCU's co-founder, told Focus that CCU receives REBNY funding. The state and city lobbying provisions we read can require reports to regulators. We found nothing in them requiring a group to tell a shareholder at a rally who funds it.
What the group is asking for.
Focus describes CCU as leading the charge for Int 0282-2026, sponsored by Council Member Linda Lee, with 22 Council sponsors. The bill would count open and green spaces toward gross floor area when calculating emissions limits for garden apartments and for condo and co-op buildings. For condo and co-op buildings averaging $65,000 or less in assessed value per unit that qualify under the law's mitigating factors, it would cut civil penalties 100 percent from 2030 through 2035, 50 percent through 2040 and 25 percent through 2045. Focus, citing the Urban Green Council, says the bill would raise the typical co-op or condo's annual emissions allowance by 11 percent. Focus's own analysis says the nearly 3,000-apartment Glen Oaks Village complex would be allowed to more than double its emissions.
The group also supports Int 0371-2026, sponsored by Council Member Vickie Paladino, which would delay Local Law 97's requirements and related penalties by seven years. Emissions limits would begin in 2031 instead of 2024.
Both proposals arise from a real financial pressure. Under NYC Administrative Code §28-320.6, the civil penalty for emissions above a building's annual limit is not more than $268 per metric ton of CO2-equivalent, and DOB's rule calculates it at that amount. A building 500 metric tons over would face $134,000 for the year, and one 1,500 metric tons over would face $402,000, before any mitigation or offsets. In our view, those numbers produce genuine political will for delay, and also consulting and contractor revenue for the firms handling the response.
Focus reports that CCU also lobbied this spring in support of Governor Hochul's push to delay New York's decarbonization timeline. CCU's stated purpose is protecting co-op shareholders and condo owners from costs they say they cannot absorb. Focus also reports that Warren Schreiber of the Presidents Co-op and Condo Council, which it says works closely with CCU, said REBNY has helped "put together the wording for some legislation that we've presented to City Council members." Focus does not tie that remark to a particular bill. CCU's argument deserves a hearing. The question this post addresses is a different one: who paid for the organization making it, and who has to say so.
The $750,000 and who reported it.
Until November 2025, the organization now called Co-ops and Condos United of NY operated as Homeowners for a Stronger New York. New York Focus reported on September 24, 2026 that the earlier group "received all its funding," over $750,000, from a lobbying group run by REBNY. City Limits republished that story the next day, so it counts as one source, not two. The figure rests on Focus's reporting. We did not independently trace it through the tax filings Focus links, and it describes money that went to the predecessor group. We found no report of the amount CCU itself receives.
REBNY is a trade association, not a co-op owner organization. Focus describes it as representing some of the city's largest developers.
In a phone interview, Mazel told Focus that CCU receives funding from REBNY but also has "a lot of support in the co-op community," and said he was not at liberty to share the amount. He added, "Nobody tells me what to do." REBNY President James Whelan told Focus that his organization is proud of the work, saying it supports such efforts "transparently, in full compliance with all legal disclosure requirements." Focus reported that CCU's website mentioned neither REBNY nor Homeowners for a Stronger New York.
Who is leading the campaign.
The launch announcement names Stuart Saft, Michael Wolfe and Geoffrey Mazel as executive members and Jane Menton as legislative director. Holland & Knight identifies Saft as its New York Real Estate Practice Group Leader. Focus reports that Mazel, formerly president of the predecessor group, is CCU's co-founder, executive member and legal advisor, and that Wolfe is a real estate consultant. Focus also reports that Mazel and Wolfe serve on REBNY's residential management council, as legal advisor and chair respectively.
Law firms advising condo and co-op boards routinely counsel on LL97 compliance, and real estate professionals work in this sector for a living. Those relationships are not improper. Our point is limited: in the lobbying provisions we read, we found no rule requiring those roles to be stated when an advocacy group asks shareholders to back legislation affecting the mandate.
The financial logic of a seven-year delay.
For co-op shareholders whose buildings exceed their 2024 emissions limit, a seven-year delay would mean seven years of fine relief. The $268-per-ton penalty, assessed annually, would not apply during that period. For buildings with modest reserves and limited retrofit capacity, that is real financial breathing room. Focus reports that the renewed J-51 program would let eligible buildings recover 100 percent of "reasonable costs" of upgrades, once the City Council authorizes the expansion, and CCU's Jane Menton replies that buildings "still have to raise the capital for these projects upfront." The city's climate office estimated for Focus that 1,300 to 1,400 co-op and condo developments are projected to exceed their limits in 2030, so in our reading the larger stakes lie in the later limits, which Int 0371 would also delay.
For LL97 compliance firms, our opinion is that the same delay would not end compliance spending. It would spread that spending over a longer and less certain runway, with more cycles of reassessment and rebidding.
Whether a seven-year delay is the right policy for co-op owners involves competing legitimate considerations: financial hardship on affordable buildings, environmental targets, and the pace at which retrofit technology is available at reasonable cost. CCNYC takes no position on that tradeoff here. Our opinion on the structural question is the one LL97 illustrates as clearly as any mandate in the extraction stack: a real estate industry group can have an interest in how a mandate is written, and owners deserve to know it when that group is paying for the campaign they are asked to join.
What New York requires of advocacy groups.
New York's Lobbying Act defines lobbying as "any attempt to influence" listed government actions, including state legislation and "the passage or defeat of any local law, ordinance, resolution, or regulation by any municipality." The law firm Holtzman Vogel summarizes the state ethics commission's position: groups engaged in grassroots lobbying must register with and report to the Commission on Ethics and Lobbying in Government (COELIG). COELIG's own rule, 19 NYCRR §943.7, defines a grassroots communication as one that references a listed government action, takes a clear position and includes a "Call to Action," and it says rallies and websites could qualify if those elements are present.
CC United NY, Inc. has a state filing. A COELIG lobbyist registration for the 2025-2026 period, the filing Focus links for the rebranding, is signed by Stuart Saft as director. It says "LEVEL OF GOVERNMENT: State," and the one bill it lists is a state bill described as real property taxes for capital improvements. It lists direct lobbying as the only type of communication, not grassroots, and says the filer anticipates exceeding the $5,000 threshold. The two bills discussed above are City Council bills. That registration does not show lobbying on them.
The state Act has a funding-source rule. Under Legislative Law §1-h(c)(4), a registered lobbyist lobbying on its own behalf, not for a client, that spends over $15,000 on reportable lobbying and at least 3 percent of its total expenditures on lobbying in New York must report to the commission "the names of each source of funding that has contributed over two thousand five hundred dollars from a single source that were used to fund the lobbying activities reported," and the amount of each contribution. The amounts need not be disclosed if they are membership dues, fees or assessments. Sources the commission finds could face harm or harassment need not be disclosed, and certain nonprofits and governmental entities are outside the requirement. That rule operates through periodic reports, not the registration we read. We could not get a reliable result from COELIG's public search and did not review CC United's bi-monthly reports, so we do not know whether it meets those thresholds or whether REBNY appears there. REBNY says it complies with all legal disclosure requirements.
City lobbying has its own law. NYC Administrative Code Title 3, Chapter 2 defines lobbying to include any attempt to influence a City Council determination on local legislation, and §3-216 requires periodic reports to the City Clerk covering compensation and expenses. We read a public mirror of the code, with annotations dating to about 2014-2015, because the official code site was not available to us, so it may not be current. In that copy we saw no funding-source requirement and no express grassroots language, and we did not determine how the chapter applies to a campaign like this one. We did not search the City Clerk's lobbyist records for CCU or REBNY on these bills.
So the gap is narrower than "no disclosure," and our conclusion is limited to what we read. Reports may exist, and a determined reader can look for them. What we did not find in those provisions is any requirement that a group tell a shareholder who funds it at the point the shareholder is asked to act: at a rally, in a member email, or on its website.
We did not find a pending bill in the City Council or the state legislature requiring advocacy groups on building mandates to disclose their funding to the owners they recruit, though our search was not exhaustive.
| Stakeholder | Effect of a 7-year LL97 delay | Disclosure duty we found |
|---|---|---|
| Co-op shareholder (over-limit building) | Annual fine relief at $268/ton for up to 7 years | Not applicable; the shareholder is the audience |
| LL97 energy consultant / retrofit firm | In our opinion, longer planning and assessment window | None found toward shareholders |
| Advocacy group and its leaders | The relief the group says it is seeking for owners | State registration where lobbying rules apply, and source-of-funding reports to COELIG above set thresholds; city lobbying reports to the City Clerk; none found, in the provisions we read, requiring funding disclosure at a rally or in member communications |
Bottom line.
Co-ops and Condos United has organized owners around a real burden. CNYC, a separate organization, reports operating-cost increases at medium-large co-ops from 2019 to 2024 that add up to about $5,859 per household, including real estate taxes, labor and insurance. Organizing over housing costs, including LL97's, is a legitimate response.
The question is not whether co-op owners should organize. It is whether a group has to tell them who funds it at the moment they are asked to act. We did not check whether REBNY already appears in public COELIG or City Clerk reports. Mazel told New York Focus that CCU receives REBNY funding. In the lobbying provisions we read, nothing requires that fact to appear in CCU's member communications or rally materials, even though state registration and reporting can apply to the group itself.
In our view, this is how gaps in New York's condo and co-op oversight tend to work: an interested party can act lawfully without the disclosure that would let owners weigh the interest. Requiring funding to be stated where the ask is made would not stop anyone from organizing. It would let owners decide with the facts in front of them.
Correction: An earlier version of this article said New York's lobbying law does not reach grassroots groups, put quotation marks around a paraphrase of Geoffrey Mazel, called him a managing agent, cited a lapsed 2023 bill, and said S8912 did not advance. The law can reach such campaigns. The article was corrected on November 5, 2026.
Primary sources: New York Focus, Sept. 24, 2026 (republished by City Limits, Sept. 25) · NYREJ, launch announcement · NYREJ, Southbridge rally · Int 0282-2026 · Int 0371-2026 · Local Law 97 of 2019, including NYC Administrative Code §28-320.6 · Legislative Law §1-c · Holtzman Vogel on grassroots lobbying · 19 NYCRR §943.7 · COELIG filing, CC United NY, Inc. · Legislative Law §1-h · NYC Admin. Code Title 3, Ch. 2, Subch. 2 (public mirror) · CNYC report · Holland & Knight on Saft
Companion resources: The NYC local-law extraction stack · LL97 first-year compliance and the 2030 cliff · CNYC's LL97 scorecard and the accountability gap · Write to your representative