New York plans 300 new affordable co-op units by 2028. We found little state law on reserves or managers.
An audit found the city's conversion program slow, and found HPD did not adequately enforce the reporting duties in its own contracts. "Our Home" is a new program, and we could not find its terms. Companion to the HDFC governance analysis.
In February 2025, the New York City Comptroller reported that the city's main affordable co-op conversion program had converted 13 of its 126 buildings since 2012, each one 15 to 87 months past HPD's benchmarks. About 15 months later, Mayor Mamdani's "Block by Block" housing plan announced "Our Home," a new conversion program, and HPD expects to support 300 new affordable co-op units in fiscal years 2027 and 2028. The existing program's day-to-day oversight comes largely from a regulatory agreement with the city, and the audit found HPD did not adequately enforce part of it. In state law we found little on reserves or managers: Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 asks for "reasonable sums" in reserves with no amount, though we did not resolve whether it reaches these co-ops; we found no statute requiring a reserve study; and there is no license specific to condo and co-op managing agents. We could not find Our Home's own terms.
What the Comptroller audit found.
The audit of HPD's Affordable Neighborhood Cooperative Program (ANCP), announced on February 14, 2025, examined the program that moves city-owned Tenant Interim Lease buildings into resident co-op ownership. Since 2012, 81 of the 126 buildings had begun the ANCP process and 13 had converted. Of the 126, 113 had not converted, and 45 of those, totaling 802 units, had no assigned developer. Conversion for all 13 finished buildings ran 15 to 87 months past HPD's benchmarks, in processes that took 6 to 11 years. HPD's original benchmark was about 48 months.
The building waiting longest entered the Tenant Interim Lease program in September 1997 and had no assigned developer at the time of the audit. HPD cited a shortage of staff and difficulties securing financing, and the auditors called the lack of a centralized way to track delays a key contributing factor. HPD agreed to build one. The audit also said that when HPD does convert a building, "the goals of ANCP are generally met." On governance it says little: "According to HPD, some co-ops struggled to thrive under TIL (governance, financial viability, as well as physical distress)." Our own view is that governance capacity deserves more attention than it got, but that is our opinion and not an audit finding.
"Our Home" is a new program the mayor says will build on this one.
On May 26, 2026, Mayor Mamdani released "Block by Block: The Housing Plan for a New Era," promising to "launch a new program, 'Our Home,' to create permanently affordable co-ops for working class New Yorkers." HousingWire reported that "HPD expects to support 300 new affordable co-op units in fiscal years 2027 and 2028." World Real Estate News, citing "combined media reports," described $75 million in loans to assist 300 renters. We could not open the plan document itself, so treat the $75 million as reported, and note that one account counts units and the other counts renters.
In June 2026, the mayor cut the ribbon at ANCP Morningside, which includes 36 affordable homes, and described Our Home as a program that "will build on the successes of ANCP to convert a wider range of buildings." It has to be a separate program: the audit says that, according to HPD, no new buildings can join ANCP, which will end when the current buildings convert. Three hundred units over two fiscal years is 150 a year. For scale, the audit counted 155 units in 11 of ANCP's 13 converted buildings as of April 2024, from a program created in 2012. That count leaves out two buildings and predates Morningside.
The rules ANCP co-ops carry, and the gap in enforcing them.
ANCP is not a rule-free zone. HPD's term sheet offers loans of up to $560,000 per unit (the audit says up to $700,000). It requires that six months of operating expenses be capitalized and that a minimum $300 per unit repair and replacement reserve be contributed from cash flow. Converted co-ops sign a regulatory agreement of at least 40 years, must retain third-party property management and a Co-op Monitor, and must submit audited financial reports and documentation of annual board elections each year. HPD's FAQ calls the agreement "a contract between the co-op and the City of New York," backed by an enforcement note and mortgage.
The stronger finding is about follow-through. The audit says HPD "did not adequately enforce the regulatory agreement requirement that co-ops submit audited financial reports and related documents, annually." Those duties exist by contract, and the audit found the city did not consistently hold co-ops to them. We found no published term sheet for Our Home, so we do not know whether its co-ops will carry the same terms, or who will check.
The state law underneath those contracts.
ANCP co-ops are Housing Development Fund Corporation co-ops, so Private Housing Finance Law Article XI matters. The audit says an HDFC co-op "must also comply with affordability requirements in Article XI." § 573 lets such a company incorporate under the Business Corporation Law, and § 576 requires a regulatory agreement as a condition of receiving an advance under that article, covering rents, profits, dividends and disposition of property. It also lets the supervising agency appoint a majority of the board if an advance is in jeopardy of not being repaid or the project of not being built. We did not establish whether ANCP or Our Home co-ops receive § 576 advances, and the sections we read do not set a reserve amount or require a reserve study. So Article XI is real state oversight, aimed at affordability and repayment. Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 says "The directors shall periodically set aside reasonable sums for reserves," with no amount. We did not resolve how far it reaches co-ops formed under the Business Corporation Law, which may include them. We found no New York statute requiring a co-op to commission a reserve study or hold a set reserve amount. The Condominium Act, Real Property Law Article 9-B, governs condominiums and not co-ops. On financial reporting, BCL § 624(e) gives a shareholder an annual balance sheet and profit and loss statement on written request. That is a right to ask, not an assessment of capital needs.
New York has no license specific to condo and co-op managing agents; whether Real Property Law § 440 reaches them is unresolved. S.71, which would require managers with 25 or more residential units in their portfolios to register and hold a certificate, went nine consecutive sessions without passing. We found no announced sponsor for 2027. See our post on that bill.
The strain on older affordable co-ops is on record. In September 2025, Attorney General James, the Adams administration and HPD announced a technical assistance pilot for HDFC co-ops, using $750,000 from Attorney General settlements to help approximately 20 to 30 of them. The release says "most HDFC co-ops are financially stable," and that "some are struggling." It reports that a recent review of the more than 1,000 HDFC co-ops in HPD's portfolio "found that a high number of these buildings are at high risk and could benefit from assistance," and that the issues "often point to a need for structural support for co-ops that could include governance issues, shareholder engagement, and legal matters."
What other states write into statute.
| Jurisdiction | What the statute says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Massachusetts (condos) | An adequate replacement reserve fund is required, though owners may modify the rule by an annual 67 percent vote. Managing agents report to the board at least quarterly, with bank statements for the reserve fund. | M.G.L. c. 183A § 10 |
| Washington | Associations must prepare and update a reserve study, with listed exemptions. Budget summaries must state whether a study exists and any reserve deficiency. | RCW 64.90.545; RCW 64.90.525 |
| Oregon (condos) | Boards annually conduct or update a reserve study. Votes to eliminate reserve funding are barred, unless the board determines the account will be adequately funded for the following year, or all owners approve skipping a year. | ORS 100.175 |
| Washington D.C. | Licensed property managers carry fiduciary duties set out in the code since 1999. We did not check D.C. reserve law. | D.C. Code § 47-2853.195 |
| New York | "Reasonable sums for reserves" for cooperative corporations, no amount, and we did not resolve its reach. Regulatory agreements for HDFCs receiving Article XI advances. We found no reserve-study requirement and no license specific to condo and co-op managing agents. | CCL § 72; PHFL § 576; S.71 |
The enforcement path when governance fails.
The Attorney General's Real Estate Finance Bureau centers on offering plans under the Martin Act, as we have written, and it is not a day-to-day forum for a dispute over a board's bylaws or reserves. That is not the whole of state power. Under BCL § 706(d), an action to remove a director for cause "may be brought by the attorney-general or by the holders of ten percent of the outstanding shares," and Executive Law § 63(12) gives the Attorney General a broad fraud remedy. Those are lawsuits, not a forum an owner can walk into.
A shareholder can also bring a derivative action under BCL § 626. The plaintiff fronts the cost, and under § 626(e) the court may award reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, if the action succeeds in whole or in part, or if the plaintiff receives something through a judgment, compromise or settlement. In our view that is a hard bargain in an affordable co-op where shareholders paid below-market prices and the sums at stake are small.
For regulated co-ops, the Comptroller's finding suggests where to look first. The tool closest to the building is the regulatory agreement and its monitor, and that is the tool the audit found under-enforced. In our opinion, before more buildings enter the pipeline, HPD should say publicly how Our Home co-ops will be monitored and what happens when reports do not arrive.
Bottom line.
New York City is starting a new affordable co-op program after an audit found the existing one slow, and found that HPD did not adequately enforce the reporting duties it wrote into its own contracts. Most HDFC co-ops are financially stable, but a recent review cited by the Attorney General found a high number at high risk, and the pilot answering that reaches about 20 to 30 of more than 1,000 buildings. Massachusetts and Oregon (for condos) and Washington put reserve duties in statute, with exceptions, and D.C. set out fiduciary duties for licensed property managers. New York's Article XI regulates HDFCs that take its advances, its § 72 says "reasonable sums" and may not reach these co-ops, and we found no license specific to condo and co-op managing agents. Our view is that what remains is a policy choice, and that Our Home's term sheet is the place to start closing it for these 300 units.
Correction: An earlier version of this article dated the Comptroller's audit November 2025 (it was February 2025), misstated its figures, attributed a governance finding to it, gave a $200,000 subsidy figure, and said these co-ops inherit no reserve duties. ANCP's terms include reserve and reporting requirements. The article was corrected on November 5, 2026.
Primary sources: NYC Comptroller audit of HPD's ANCP (Feb. 2025) · Comptroller's announcement (Feb. 14, 2025) · HPD: ANCP term sheet · HPD: ANCP FAQ · NYC Mayor's Office: Block by Block (May 2026) · NYC Mayor's Office: ANCP Morningside (June 2026) · HousingWire on the plan · World Real Estate News on the plan · AG James: HDFC pilot launch (Sept. 2025) · Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 · PHFL § 573 · PHFL § 576 · BCL § 624 · BCL § 626 · BCL § 706 · S.71
Companion resources: New York has $22 billion to build affordable homes and $750,000 to save the ones it already built · Why the AG can't help with most condo governance disputes · The senator who carried New York's managing-agent bill is leaving. We found no announced successor for 2027. · Your home is not an investment. It's a point of extraction. · How to write an AG REFB complaint