← BLOG

A co-op resident says her building overpaid property taxes for 40 years. The city fixed the number and, she says, refused a refund.

ABC7 reported in August that the Department of Finance had the wrong square footage on file for an Upper West Side co-op. A resident says the building overpaid for more than 40 years. Records show the number was fixed going forward, and she says the city denied the refund request. For applications filed now, DOF's rule is tighter than the one that building faced.

A NYC co-op's property tax bill depends on data the Department of Finance holds, and we found no statute requiring a board to audit it. When that data contains an error, such as a wrong square footage, the building can overpay for years. Boards have ways to challenge the number. How much money comes back, if any, depends on a DOF rule that was tightened in January 2025, and on what DOF decides.

Why square footage matters.

Under Real Property Tax Law § 581, a co-op or condo is assessed at "a sum not exceeding the assessment which would be placed upon such parcel were the parcel not owned or leased by a cooperative corporation or on a condominium basis." ABC7 describes the city's calculation as "a complicated formula, based on the amount of livable square footage." On ABC7's account, a wrong figure can affect the bill for as long as it stays on file. We found no rule requiring anyone to verify that the number on file matches the building.

What boards can do when the number is wrong.

The Tax Commission hears challenges to assessed value. Notices of Property Value go out on or about January 15, and for Tax Class 2 the Commission must receive the application by March 1. DOF's rules add two routes of its own. A Request for Review, open to class two owners from January 15 to March 1, can address valuation errors and purely ministerial errors. A clerical error application, under Administrative Code § 11-206 and 19 RCNY Chapter 53, covers errors that are purely ministerial or a mistaken conclusion of fact that city-created documents can unambiguously resolve. DOF says it will not correct errors resulting from a discretionary act or judgment. An Upper West Side co-op board used the clerical error route in 2023 after, a resident says, an architect it hired during building work found a discrepancy. The city's figure went from 119,228 square feet to 93,759.

Path Filed with Deadline What it resolves
Tax Commission application NYC Tax Commission Received by March 1 (Class 2), after the January 15 notice Tax class, assessed value, exemption
Request for Review Department of Finance January 15 to March 1 (class two) Valuation errors; purely ministerial errors and errors of description
Clerical error application Department of Finance No annual date, but only errors in the application year and two preceding tax years, with limited exceptions Purely ministerial errors or mistaken conclusions of fact, such as a wrong square footage if city documents resolve it
Article 7 petition Supreme Court, county where the property sits By October 24 of the tax year, per a practitioner guide; confirm with counsel Judicial review after a Tax Commission application

What boards are required to do when the calculation looks wrong.

We found no statute specifically requiring a board to audit DOF's records. Business Corporation Law § 624 gives co-op shareholders certain access to records, and Real Property Law § 339-w requires condo boards to keep receipts and expenditures open to unit owners. Neither mentions assessment review. Co-op directors do owe a general duty under BCL § 717 to act "in good faith and with that degree of care which an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances." We did not find a case applying that duty to assessment review, so we cannot say whether a board that never checked its square footage would be in breach.

Two prior tax years is now the default, whatever the error's age.

From 2016, DOF's rule let it correct errors that occurred within six years of an application. The amended 19 RCNY § 53-01(a)(3), effective January 5, 2025, covers errors "during the tax year in which an application for correction of errors was submitted, the two directly preceding tax years, or any combination of such tax years." Earlier years are possible only if correction would not unduly prejudice DOF and the filer documents a medical condition or a declared emergency that prevented an earlier request. DOF says the change addresses "certain misuses of the lengthy time period," such as relitigating after a tax certiorari result. ABC7 summarizes the change as six years to three. A new owner generally cannot collect a refund for years before it owned the property unless it shows it reimbursed the former owner's payments.

The Upper West Side application predates that rule. According to ABC7, "Records show it was fixed moving forward," and resident Ellen Silverman says the city denied the building's request for a prorated refund for the previous six years. She estimates the building overpaid for more than 40 years, which she calls "millions of dollars." ABC7 does not report DOF's reason for the denial, and DOF declined an interview. ABC7 reports that an Upper East Side resident's building got "only a two-year refund." Stan Russo, a property tax consultant, said, "I cannot remember the last time they gave a refund to a building that I've been involved in." DOF's statement to the station was: "We encourage property owners who disagree with DOF's property valuations to appeal to the Tax Commission."

Who was supposed to check is not in the record.

ABC7's report does not mention a managing agent, and whether one had this job would depend on a contract the station does not report. There is no license specific to condo and co-op managing agents. Senate Bill S.71, which would require registration and a certificate, has not left the Senate Judiciary Committee, has no Assembly companion, and does not name assessment review. Read more at the managing agent licensure gap issue page.

Bottom line.

New York City gives co-op and condo boards several ways to challenge a property tax error: the Tax Commission by March 1, DOF's Request for Review, the clerical error application, and an Article 7 petition. We found no statute requiring a board to use any of them or to look for errors. A building that finds an old error today faces a clerical error window of the application year and two prior tax years, with narrow exceptions, and DOF's decision whether to act. The Upper West Side resident's account is that even under the older six-year rule, her building got its number fixed and no refund. For the owners of New York City's 15,108 co-op and condo buildings, the practical advice is plain: compare the square footage DOF has on file with your building's records, and get advice on any difference before the March 1 routes close. In our view, a rule that limits recovery this tightly for an error in the city's own records deserves a second look.

Correction: An earlier version of this article said the city refunded six years of overpayments, cited the wrong code section, said S.71 had passed the Senate, and gave a wrong court deadline. A resident says the refund was denied; the rule is 19 RCNY § 53-01(a)(3); S.71 has not passed; the Article 7 deadline is October 24, per a practitioner guide. The article was corrected on November 5, 2026.

Primary sources: ABC7, August 12, 2026 · DOF final rule effective January 5, 2025 · NYC Tax Commission · Rosenberg & Estis on Article 7 petitions · RPTL § 581 · BCL § 624 · BCL § 717 · RPL § 339-w · S.71

Companion resources: Managing agent licensure gap · How NYC values co-ops under RPTL § 581 · Write to your state legislator about S.71 · 421-a abatement calculator