Fannie Mae's 15% reserve floor is worded for condos. A New York practitioner tells co-ops not to assume an exemption.
The percentage in Lender Letter LL-2026-03 amends a condo requirement. The Selling Guide's co-op section does not carry a percentage. Companion to Fannie Mae's 15% reserve floor arrives in January, the condo version of this deadline.
Fannie Mae Lender Letter LL-2026-03 raises the minimum reserve allocation in a condo budget from 10% to 15% of annual budgeted assessment income, for loan applications dated January 4, 2027 or later. NYC co-op boards are working through their 2027 budgets now, and some are being told the same 15% binds them. The text of the Fannie Mae Selling Guide as published November 4, 2026 words the percentage for condos. The co-op standard is "adequate replacement and operating reserves," with no number attached, and the lender decides what adequate means. Our reading of the text differs from at least one New York practitioner's, and Fannie Mae's current text does not settle it in so many words.
Where the 15 percent actually lives.
The percentage test for a lender's Full Review of a condo appears in B4-2.2-01, Full Review Process. It reads: "Lenders must review the HOA projected budget to determine that it is adequate (that is, it includes allocations for line items pertinent to the type of condo project), and provides for the funding of replacement reserves for capital expenditures and deferred maintenance that is at least 10% of the budget."
LL-2026-03's reserve-allocation item changes that number: "We are revising our reserve allocation requirement for capital expenditures and deferred maintenance from a minimum of 10% to a minimum of 15% of the annual budgeted income assessment. All other requirements related to replacement reserves and the review of budget adequacy remained unchanged." The letter's stated reason is framed around condos throughout. Fannie Mae writes that it has "seen a correlation between condo projects with underfunded reserves for capital expenditures and those in need of critical repairs." An amendment raises an existing requirement. The co-op section has no 10% test, so there is nothing there for the letter to raise.
What the co-op section requires instead.
Co-op project eligibility is governed by B4-2.3-02, Co-op Project Eligibility. Its financial test says the project's most recent operating budget and two most recent years of audited financial statements, or corporate tax returns, "must be consistent with the nature of the project, provide for adequate cash flow to service the current debt and operating expenses, and provide for adequate replacement and operating reserves."
That is the whole reserve standard in B4-2.3-02 for an established co-op. It sets no percentage, requires no reserve study and prescribes no funding method. A newly converted co-op that was not a gut rehabilitation is different: it must go through Fannie Mae's PERS review, and B4-2.2-04 requires "a current reserve study" for it. Freddie Mac's co-op section, Guide 5705.4, uses the same "adequate replacement and operating reserves" wording. We could not open Freddie's own page, so we checked that text through a secondary copy rather than Freddie's own site.
| Fannie Mae test | Condo project (B4-2.2-01) | Co-op project (B4-2.3-02) |
|---|---|---|
| Budgeted reserve allocation | At least 10% of budgeted assessment income; 15% for applications dated on or after Jan. 4, 2027 | "Adequate replacement and operating reserves." No percentage. |
| Reserve study in place of the percentage | Allowed if under 3 years old and the budget includes the study's highest recommended allocation; baseline funding not accepted | No reserve-study provision for an established co-op |
| Delinquency limit | No more than 15% of units 60+ days past due on assessments or on each special assessment | No more than 15% of owners 60+ days past due, including each special assessment |
| Projects in need of critical repairs (B4-2.1-03) | Ineligible | Ineligible |
The argument that co-ops are covered, and what the text says.
There is one route to the opposite reading. Fannie Mae's project standards overview, B4-2.1-01, lists "Full Review" as the review method for a unit in a co-op project. LL-2026-03 says lenders must apply the 15% "when utilizing the Full Review process." Read together, those two lines suggest co-ops are swept in. One law-firm client alert takes that view. Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis, a New Jersey firm, wrote on August 12, 2026 that condo and co-op projects undergoing Full Review were already required to allocate 10%. John Dolgetta, writing for the Hudson Gateway Association of Realtors on September 3, 2026, told boards to budget toward 15% and said: "Do not assume co-ops are exempt."
In our reading, the Guide's own wording points the other way. The 10% sentence is written for an "HOA projected budget" and "the type of condo project." The co-op financial requirements in B4-2.3-02 contain no percentage at all. The letter changes the number in the condo sentence, and that sentence is not written for co-ops. That is our reading of the text, not a statement from Fannie Mae, so a board should not treat it as settled.
Two caveats. First, Fannie Mae has not yet published the rewritten Guide text for the January 4 change; the condo section still prints 10%. If co-op language is coming, it would arrive in that update. Second, the lender decides what "adequate" means for a given building. Fannie Mae buys co-op share loans only from lenders "specially approved to sell such loans" to it (B4-2.3-02). A lender can impose its own reserve ratio as a condition of lending in the building, with or without Fannie Mae requiring one.
What does apply to co-ops today.
A co-op board that concludes the 15% is not written for it still has live Fannie Mae tests to meet, and in our view several of them carry more weight in an NYC budget than the reserve line does.
- Critical repairs. B4-2.1-03 makes a project ineligible while major safety or structural repairs are outstanding, and the co-op column of that table is checked. The triggers include a project that "failed to pass state, county, or other jurisdictional mandatory inspections or certifications specific to structural safety, soundness, and habitability," and "any unfunded repairs costing more than $10,000 per unit that should be undertaken within the next 12 months." Repairs funded through a special assessment are excluded from that dollar test, but a special assessment tied to one of those repairs that has not been fixed leaves the project ineligible. In NYC, the inspection most likely to raise the question is the Local Law 11 facade inspection. That is our reading of how a lender would apply the rule; Fannie Mae does not name FISP.
- Delinquencies. No more than 15% of owners may be more than 60 days late on their obligations to the co-op corporation, and the limit applies to each special assessment as well. This is the 15% in Fannie Mae's rules that does reach co-ops, and it is easy to confuse with the reserve number.
- Negative cash flow. Any negative cash flow for the present year may not exceed 5% of the most recent audited financial statement, may not come with two consecutive years of operating loss, and must be attributable to an isolated, non-recurring expense.
- Expiring tax benefits. If the project receives subsidies or tax or assessment abatements that will end partly or fully within the next three years, the lender must evaluate the impact. If the benefit expires within three years of the note date, the lender must count the higher monthly fees in the buyer's debt-to-income ratio. In our view, that can shrink the buyer pool before the abatement actually ends.
- Insurance. The co-op project must meet Fannie Mae's insurance requirements in Subpart B7. LL-2026-03 also revised master-policy deductible rules for project developments, effective for applications dated on or after July 1, 2026.
What a co-op board can do before the 2027 budget is adopted.
- Ask the lenders, not the Lender Letter. Find out which two or three lenders write most share loans in your building and ask what reserve benchmark their co-op questionnaire tests. That answer decides whether a buyer's loan closes.
- Put the question to Fannie Mae directly. Fannie Mae runs a policy question tool, "Ask Poli," linked from every Selling Guide page, and LL-2026-03 says "Lenders may contact their Fannie Mae Account Team if they have questions about this Lender Letter."
- Document "adequate" with a reserve study. B4-2.3-02 does not require one for an established co-op. A current study by an independent professional still gives the board a written, defensible basis for its reserve line, whatever number a lender has in mind.
- Check the safety-repair exposure first. An Unsafe facade (FISP) filing, which in our reading a lender may treat as a failed inspection, an unfunded repair above $10,000 per unit due within a year, or an assessment tied to an unfixed safety repair can make the building ineligible regardless of how its reserve line is set.
No floor from Albany, no stated co-op floor from Fannie Mae.
We found no New York law setting an ongoing budget-reserve percentage for co-ops. Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 says "The directors shall periodically set aside reasonable sums for reserves," with no amount. For a rental building converted under an offering plan, NYC Administrative Code § 26-703 has the sponsor of a conversion fund a capital reserve, generally totaling three percent of the price. Neither sets a yearly budget line, which is New York's reserve gap. Senate Bill S7600 (Sen. Bynoe), which would direct condominium and cooperative housing associations to complete capital reserve studies with a 30-year funding plan, has not passed either chamber. For condos, Fannie Mae's percentage has become the nearest thing New York has to a reserve floor, a point made in our post on the business judgment rule. For an established co-op, Fannie Mae's text states no such number. In our view the yearly reserve line is, in practice, whatever the board adopts and the lenders accept.
Bottom line.
On the current text of the Selling Guide, Fannie Mae's 15% reserve floor is worded as a condo requirement. NYC co-op boards are held in that text to "adequate replacement and operating reserves," judged by each lender, with no percentage in B4-2.3-02 and none we found in New York law for the yearly budget. A New York practitioner advises boards not to assume they are exempt, and a lender can set its own number. That is not a reason to budget less. It means the board should be able to show its work: a reserve study, a lender's stated benchmark, and a capital plan that keeps facade and structural repairs funded. Watch the Selling Guide update that implements the January 4 change. If Fannie Mae adds co-op language, this post will say so.
Editor's note: An earlier CondosCoopsNYC article, published September 26, 2026, stated as settled that the 15 percent floor applies to co-ops. It has been corrected. This article was prompted by a reader's question about it.
Correction: An earlier version of this article said flatly in its headline and text that the 15% floor is a condo rule and that it does not bind co-ops. The floor is worded for condos, and a New York practitioner disagrees on co-ops. The article was corrected on November 5, 2026.
Correction, November 15, 2026: An earlier version cited the condo reserve test as Selling Guide B4-2.2-02; it is B4-2.2-01. It also said the co-op rules require no reserve study and that New York law sets no co-op reserve, without noting the PERS reserve-study rule for newly converted co-ops, Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 or NYC Administrative Code § 26-703, and it attributed one New York practitioner's advice to several.
Primary sources: Fannie Mae Lender Letter LL-2026-03 (Mar. 18, 2026) · Selling Guide B4-2.2-01, Full Review Process · Selling Guide B4-2.2-04, PERS · Selling Guide B4-2.3-02, Co-op Project Eligibility · Selling Guide B4-2.1-01, General Information on Project Standards · Selling Guide B4-2.1-03, Ineligible Projects · NY Senate Bill S7600 · NY Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 · NYC Admin. Code § 26-703 · John Dolgetta, HGAR, Sept. 3, 2026
Companion resources: Fannie Mae's 15% reserve floor arrives in January (condos) · How to check your condo's Fannie Mae reserve compliance · How NYC co-ops fund capital work: flip taxes and assessments (corrected) · What your reserve study's funding method means after August 3 · Issue: No reserve fund requirement