Hawaii has made annual condo audits the default since 1985. We found no equivalent in New York's Condominium Act.
New York's Condominium Act requires boards to report to unit owners annually. It sets no form for that report and, as we read it, requires no audit. Companion to New Jersey mandated reserve studies for condos. New York still hasn't.
In New York, a condo board must give unit owners a written report summarizing receipts and expenditures at least once a year (RPL § 339-w). We found no statute requiring a certified public accountant to touch it, or an audit to exist. The Attorney General's rules we read for newly constructed condominiums reach certified statements while an offering stays open and the sponsor controls the board (13 NYCRR 20.5). Hawaii drew a different line long ago: a 1985 act required a yearly audit of association accounts, and today's HRS § 514B-150, in effect since July 1, 2006, requires an annual audit plus at least one annual unannounced cash balance verification by a public accountant. New York's Condominium Act still contains no equivalent provision that we could find.
What HRS § 514B-150 requires.
The language of HRS § 514B-150 is direct: "The association shall require an annual audit of the association financial accounts and no less than one annual unannounced verification of the association's cash balance by a public accountant." Both duties exist by operation of law, not by board vote. The section came in with Act 164 of 2004, which Act 93 of 2005 set to take effect on July 1, 2006. But the duty is older. Hawaii's Act 212 of 1985 required a yearly audit, and Act 96 of 1986 turned the second check into an unannounced cash balance verification by a public accountant, striking "certified." Both the 1985 and 1986 texts let a majority of all apartment owners waive the audits, whatever the association's size. Today only associations under 20 units may.
One carve-out applies today: if the association has fewer than 20 units, the annual audit and the annual unannounced cash balance verification may be waived at an association meeting by a vote of a majority of the unit owners.
The unannounced cash balance verification is worth noting separately. As we read it, it is a check on the money itself, on a date management does not choose. We found nothing like it in New York's Condominium Act.
The practical effect of § 514B-150 is that a Hawaii condo with 20 or more units gets an annual audit and an unannounced verification, which we read as both by a public accountant, not merely a statement compiled by the managing agent. The board must make a copy available to each unit owner at least 30 days before the annual meeting, though it need not send one to an owner whose proxy form does not ask for it. § 514B-154 separately gives owners the most current financial statement. The audit requirement creates a statutory floor. We found none in New York's Condominium Act.
The reserve study mandate that accompanies it.
Section 514B-150 does not stand alone. Hawaii pairs the audit requirement with a reserve study regime under HRS § 514B-148.
Since the chapter took effect in 2006, the budget has had to show estimated replacement reserves "based on a reserve study performed by the association" (Act 164). Independent review came later. Act 62 of 2022, effective January 1, 2023, added review by an independent reserve study preparer at least every three years. The section now says a study "if not prepared by an independent reserve study preparer, shall be reviewed by an independent reserve study preparer no less than every three years." Act 100 of 2026 (H.B. 1824, June 5, 2026) lets an association of fewer than 20 units and no more than two stories waive that review by a majority of owners present or represented, for a single three-year period and not twice in a row.
The statute also sets a funding floor, in place since the 2004 act. The association must assess owners to fund at least 50 percent of the estimated replacement reserves assessments, or 100 percent under a cash flow plan. A cash flow plan is now a projection of at least 30 years that does not include special assessments or loans, except in an emergency; a separate clause lets a study forecast a loan or special assessment for fire safety work in counties over 500,000 people. Either way, the plan "shall not circumvent" the amount the study determines, and any unit owner has standing to sue the association to enforce the section.
Act 62 also extended the disclosure chain to the sale: a developer's public report must now include annual reserve contributions "based on a reserve study" under HRS § 514B-83, and that study need not be independent. The reserve study therefore runs from sale through the association's operating life. In New York, the closest thing we found at the sale end is an Attorney General rule, not a statute: offering plans must "Disclose whether the yearly reserve fund will be sufficient" for capital needs in the first five years (13 NYCRR 20.3). Real Property Law § 339-mm funds a reserve, but only in preservation-plan conversions. At the operating end, § 339-v requires bylaws to contain "provisions governing the payment, collection and disbursement of funds, including reserves," with no amount.
What New York's Condominium Act actually says.
New York Real Property Law Article 9-B addresses financial reporting in RPL § 339-w. The board of managers must keep "detailed, accurate records" of receipts and expenditures, and "A written report summarizing such receipts and expenditures shall be rendered by the board of managers to all unit owners at least once annually." We searched the Act's sections, and that is the financial reporting mandate we found.
The Act does not prescribe the report's form, specify that a CPA must prepare or review it, or require an opinion letter. The records are the board's to maintain. An audit of those records is the board's to commission, or not, unless its own documents say otherwise.
The First Department has held that condo owners' inspection rights are not governed by Business Corporation Law § 624, because condo associations are generally unincorporated; § 339-w governs instead (Pomerance v McGrath, 2016). Those rights are real. Owners may examine the records and vouchers "at convenient hours of weekdays," and Pomerance adds the right to make copies at their own expense. But the right to examine books is not a right to an independent audit opinion on them. Section 339-w names no agency and no penalty, and Pomerance shows the route an owner may have to take: a lawsuit.
A building's bylaws may go further, and at the offering stage the Attorney General's rules have the first-year budget price audit fees from "a fee quotation from a certified public accountant for preparing the yearly certified financial statement for the condominium" (13 NYCRR 20.3). We did not survey bylaws. But where a CPA requirement exists, it comes from those documents, not from the Condominium Act, and so it can vary building by building across the 10,882 condos in New York City.
Side by side: Hawaii and New York.
| Requirement | Hawaii (HRS Ch. 514B) | New York |
|---|---|---|
| Annual financial audit | Required; owners may waive by majority vote below 20 units (§ 514B-150) | No statute found; AG rules we read for newly constructed condominiums reach certified statements while an offering stays open and the sponsor controls the board |
| Annual cash balance verification | Required; unannounced, by public accountant; same waiver (§ 514B-150) | No statute found |
| Reserve study | Basis for the budget since 2006; independent review every 3 years since 2023, with a small-association waiver added in 2026 (§ 514B-148) | No statute found; S7600 and A8945 did not pass |
| Minimum reserve funding floor | 50% of replacement reserves assessments; 100% under cash flow plan (§ 514B-148) | No number found; RPL § 339-v lets by-laws provide for reserves; RPL § 339-mm funds a reserve in preservation-plan conversions only |
| Developer reserve disclosure at sale | Reserve contributions based on study in public report (§ 514B-83, as amended by Act 62 of 2022) | AG rule, not statute: disclose whether the yearly reserve fund is sufficient for the first five years (13 NYCRR 20.3) |
| Owner financial record access | Most current financial statement (§ 514B-154); audit copy (§ 514B-150) | RPL § 339-w: examine records and vouchers, annual written report (no audit mandate) |
What Fannie Mae's 2026 rule changes reveal.
Two Fannie Mae rule changes made the reserve study gap more concrete in 2026. Lender Letter LL-2026-03 retires the Limited Review process for established condos for loan applications dated on or after August 3, 2026: those projects now go through Full Review or, for projects of ten or fewer units, possibly a waiver. That is a project review for loans sold to Fannie Mae, not a rule on every mortgage. For buildings that use a reserve study to satisfy the reserve test, the same letter adds a requirement: lenders must verify that the budget includes "the highest recommended reserve allocation amount" in the study, and they may no longer use the baseline funding method. In effect, a lender's rule is imposing a test we did not find in New York's Condominium Act.
For loan applications dated on or after January 4, 2027, Full Review raises the required reserve allocation from 10 percent to 15 percent "of the annual budgeted income assessment" under the same Lender Letter. That is a budget test, not a test of the reserve balance, and a qualifying reserve study remains an alternative. A project that meets neither fails Fannie's Full Review. In our view, that 15 percent line works as a market proxy for a kind of floor Hawaii wrote into statute long ago.
The difference is where the requirement operates. Fannie Mae's regime works through loan eligibility: a building with thin reserves does not face a government audit, mandatory owner disclosure, or state enforcement. It faces the loss of Fannie-eligible financing when a unit sells or refinances, which may be years after the board set the reserve contribution. Hawaii's approach operates at the source. The reserve study underlies the annual budget, gets independent review at least every three years unless a small association waives it, and carries a statutory funding floor. The audit is an annual outside check. The budget carries a reserve summary, and the board must make the audit available to owners under § 514B-150(b). Among New York City's 15,108 condo and co-op buildings, the 10,882 condos have no comparable statutory guarantee on either document that we could find; co-ops answer to separate corporate law that we did not compare here.
Bottom line.
Hawaii has made annual condo audits the default since 1985. Since July 1, 2006, its current statute has also required budgets based on a reserve study with a funding floor, and since 2023, independent review of that study at least every three years. Associations under 20 units may waive the audit, and those also of no more than two stories may waive the reserve review for one period at a time. We found neither an audit requirement nor a reserve study requirement in New York's Condominium Act. Unit owners in New York have a statutory right to examine receipts, expenditures and vouchers, but may have to sue to enforce it. We found no statute they can invoke to require an audit to exist or a reserve study to be performed. New York bills A8945 and S7600 would have imposed a reserve study requirement. S7600 was reported to Finance in May 2025 and was back in Judiciary in January 2026, A8945 stayed in Housing, and neither received a floor vote before the 2026 session concluded on June 5. In our view, the reserve-study half of the gap is what remains when those bills do not move. Those bills address reserve studies, not annual audits of association accounts.
Correction: An earlier version of this article dated Hawaii's audit mandate and its independent reserve review to 2006; they date to 1985 and 2023. It also said New York owners could inspect records only if bylaws permitted, said no state agency could demand an audit, and overstated Fannie Mae's 15 percent test. The article was corrected on November 5, 2026.
Primary sources: HRS § 514B-150 (audits) · HRS § 514B-148 (budgets and reserves) · HRS § 514B-83 · HRS § 514B-154 · Hawaii Act 212 (1985) · Hawaii Act 96 (1986) · Hawaii Act 164 (2004) · Hawaii Act 93 (2005) · Hawaii Act 62 (2022) · Act 62: Imanaka Asato analysis · Hawaii H.B. 1824 C.D. 1 (Act 100 of 2026) · NY RPL § 339-w · NY RPL § 339-v · NY RPL § 339-mm · Pomerance v McGrath (digest) · 13 NYCRR 20.3 · 13 NYCRR 20.5 · Fannie Mae LL-2026-03 (lender-hosted copy) · NY S7600 actions · NY A8945 actions
Companion resources: New Jersey mandated reserve studies for condos. New York still hasn't. · What NYC condo and co-op owners can legally demand from the board · Fannie Mae's 15% reserve floor arrives in January · Fannie Mae-backed NYC condo loans in projects over 10 units go to full review on August 3 · No independent audit requirement issue page · No reserve fund requirement issue page · All regulatory gaps →