New York's Senate has passed a condo owner's bill of rights six times since 2019. The Assembly has not advanced it.
Senate Bill S5089 cleared the full Senate in April 2025 and again in March 2026 with no dissent, and earlier versions passed in 2019, 2022, 2023 and 2024. To our knowledge, it would give the AG the first explicit statutory basis to take a condo owner's complaint on these rights, but only in associations of 3,500 or more units. Neither its Assembly same-as nor a broader Assembly bill was reported from the Housing Committee. Companion to Why the NY AG's Real Estate Finance Bureau can't resolve most condo governance disputes.
The New York Senate has passed S5089, the Residential Condominium Owner's Bill of Rights, twice this term: on April 30, 2025, by 60-0 with 2 excused, and on March 18, 2026, by 61-0 with 2 excused. Earlier versions passed the Senate four times: S1751 on June 18, 2019 (62-0), S3017 on May 18, 2022 (61-0, 2 excused), and S3320 on March 30, 2023 (62-0, 1 excused) and May 7, 2024 (60-0, 2 excused). Its only Assembly same-as, A5227, was referred to the Housing Committee and not reported from it. So was a separate, broader bill, A1505. The 2026 session concluded June 5 with no committee report or floor vote in the Assembly on either.
What S5089 would give condo unit owners.
Current New York law gives condo owners and co-op shareholders different statutory inspection rights. For condos, Real Property Law §339-w says records of receipts and expenditures "and the vouchers authorizing the payments shall be available for examination by the unit owners at convenient hours of weekdays," and requires a written summary report at least once a year. For co-ops, Business Corporation Law §624 lets a shareholder of record, on five days' written demand, examine the minutes of shareholder proceedings and the record of shareholders, and request an annual balance sheet and profit and loss statement. A condo unit owner is not a shareholder, so §624 is not a condo owner's right.
Section 339-w does not mention board-meeting minutes, engineer or consultant reports, or municipal inspection reports, and §624(b) does not list board minutes. Neither section requires a board to give written reasons for a decision or names an agency to enforce it. §624(d) points a refused shareholder to Supreme Court. Other rights may come from a building's declaration or bylaws, or from court decisions, which we did not survey here.
S5089 proposed to change several of those defaults for the associations it covers. Financial statements, reports of hired accountants and consultants, reports by municipal or county inspectors, and approved board minutes would "be available for review within a timely fashion of a request to review, inspect, or copy." Board decisions on owner applications would have to be in writing with reasons, except approvals. Election results, with vote tallies, would be posted within one business day. The board would have to "call a meeting to fill any vacancies" within sixty days when a vacancy occurs more than six months before the annual meeting. At least every five years, the board would propose expense limits that owners could comment on before a vote. After that, it could not contract for extraordinary expenses without owner approval "unless it is deemed to be an emergency or is required for refinancing of the mortgage."
Records rights of this kind exist in other states' condominium statutes. Florida Statute §718.111 says failing to provide records "within 10 working days after receipt of a written request creates a rebuttable presumption that the association willfully failed to comply." Virginia's Condominium Act §55.1-1945 opens books and records to "a unit owner in good standing or his authorized agent" for a proper purpose, on five business days' written notice, or ten for a self-managed association, subject to the exclusions in its subsection C.
The 3,500-unit threshold: who S5089 would actually cover.
The structural limit in S5089 is its scope clause. The bill applies to "the organizational and operating documents of a not-for-profit residential condominium association established or operating pursuant to the laws of the state and managing the common charges, elements, expenses, or profits of thirty-five hundred or more units." Three thousand five hundred units.
The threshold does reach real places. Parkchester in the Bronx is the example we can document: a 2018 City Limits opinion piece by a participant in its rescue describes a North Condominium of "slightly less than 4,000 residential units" and a South Condominium "with more than 8,000." Those associations look large enough to qualify, though we did not check their current unit counts or legal form against the bill. But in our reading, associations of that size are rare, and the threshold leaves out most of the 10,882 condo buildings in the 15,108-building universe this site tracks. We have not counted them one by one. The sponsor memo does not explain why the number was chosen.
| Right | Current condo statute (RPL §339-w) | S5089 (for associations 3,500+ units) |
|---|---|---|
| Financial records | Records of receipts and expenditures and vouchers open for examination; annual summary report | Financial statements and accountant and consultant reports, "within a timely fashion of a request" |
| Board-meeting minutes | Not listed in §339-w; check the declaration and bylaws | Approved minutes available on request and posted |
| Municipal inspection reports | Not listed in §339-w | Reports by municipal or county inspectors available on request |
| Election results | Not addressed in §339-w | Results and vote tallies posted within one business day |
| Board vacancies | Not addressed in §339-w | Board must call a meeting within 60 days if the vacancy arises 6+ months before the annual meeting |
| Extraordinary expenses | Not addressed in §339-w; governed by building documents | Once expense limits are adopted, owner approval needed absent emergency or mortgage refinancing |
| Enforcement | §339-w names no agency and no remedy | AG can investigate on own initiative or on complaint; AG handbook within 6 months |
One same-as and one broader bill. Neither was reported from committee.
A5227, introduced February 12, 2025, by Assembly members Reyes, Sayegh, Jacobson, Simon, DeStefano, Cruz, and Taylor, with Cook and Epstein as multi-sponsors, is S5089's same-as, with identical text including the 3,500-unit threshold. Its action history shows referrals to Housing on February 12, 2025, and January 7, 2026.
A1505, introduced January 10, 2025, by Assembly member Rosenthal, is a separate bill, not a companion. It amends the General Business Law and the Business Corporation Law and covers both condo owners and co-op shareholders. It applies to "every residential condominium established or operating pursuant to the laws of the state" and "every residential cooperative established or operating pursuant to the laws of the state," with no 3,500-unit clause. It carries the same AG enforcement language. Its history shows referrals to Housing on January 10, 2025, and January 7, 2026.
An action history cannot show whether a hearing was ever held, but it does show that neither bill was reported from committee or voted on. A bill not enacted by the end of the 2025-2026 term would need to be reintroduced in 2027, and any version must pass both houses in identical form before going to the Governor.
The AG enforcement gap that S5089 would address.
The enforcement structure S5089 proposed matters as much as the rights themselves. The bill specified that "the attorney general is authorized to enforce the provisions of this section and may, upon the attorney general's own initiative, or in response to a complaint by one or more unit owners, investigate allegations of any failure to comply." The AG would also be required to produce a handbook summarizing unit owners' rights and available enforcement procedures within six months of the bill's effective date.
Compare that to the current framework. As CCNYC explains in Why the NY AG's Real Estate Finance Bureau can't resolve most condo governance disputes, the Bureau's core work is offering-plan disclosure, and it is not a tribunal that orders corrective action building by building. The AG is not powerless: BCL §706(d) lets the Attorney General or holders of 10 percent of shares sue to remove a director of a corporation for cause, a route for co-ops rather than condos. In the sections of the Condominium Act (Real Property Law Article 9-B) we read, including §339-w, we found no provision directing the AG to take a condo owner's records or vacancy complaint and enforce it.
S5089, in the form the Senate approved, would create, to our knowledge, the first explicit statutory basis for the AG to receive such a complaint from a condo unit owner and investigate it. The caveat remains: because of the 3,500-unit threshold, that pathway would reach only the largest associations.
Bottom line.
New York's Senate has passed this condo owner's bill of rights six times since 2019, each time with no votes against, and the Assembly has not advanced it. The bill's own scope clause limits it to associations managing 3,500 or more units, which may reach places like Parkchester and, in our reading, leaves out most New York City condominiums. The broader Assembly bill, A1505, would extend similar rights to condos and co-ops without that threshold, and it was not reported from committee either. If either is reintroduced in 2027, the threshold decides whether it covers most NYC condo owners, and the enforcement clause decides whether those rights can be enforced. In our view, a bill of rights that applies only in the largest associations leaves most owners where they are now: with §339-w, their building documents, and the courts.
Correction: An earlier version of this article said RPL §339-w covers six fiscal years, which it does not; treated BCL §624 as a condo owner's right; omitted the Senate's March 2026 and earlier passages; called A1505 a companion bill; said the bills never had a hearing, which action histories cannot show; and said Albany adjourned June 18 (June 5). The article was corrected on November 4 and 5, 2026.
Primary sources: NY Senate Bill S5089 (2025-2026) · S5089 bill text · S1751 (2019-2020) · S3017 (2021-2022) · S3320 (2023-2024) · NY Assembly Bill A5227 (2025-2026) · NY Assembly Bill A1505 (2025-2026) · A1505 bill text · NY Real Property Law §339-w · NY Business Corporation Law §624 · NY Business Corporation Law §706 · Florida Statute §718.111 · Virginia Code §55.1-1945 · City Limits, CityViews on Parkchester (Aug. 22, 2018)
Companion resources: Why the NY AG's Real Estate Finance Bureau can't resolve most condo governance disputes. · When Albany Adjourned in June, Four Co-op Reform Bills Had No Vote · New York's Condo-Reform Record: What Stalled, and What Passed · NY's Condo Ombudsman Bill Did Not Advance for the Second Consecutive Session · What NYC Condo and Co-op Owners Can Legally Demand From the Board · All regulatory gaps →