NYC passed COPA. For BCL co-ops it could create, we found no ongoing reserve floor and no license specific to managing agents.
The City Council passed the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act on October 22, 2026. Some buildings it touches could convert to resident-owned co-ops. We found no reserve requirement, license specific to managing agents, or administrative enforcement forum in New York's Business Corporation Law, and whether a separate law's call for "reasonable sums" for reserves reaches co-ops formed under it is unsettled.
On October 22, 2026, the New York City Council passed Intro 905-A, the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, on a 38-to-9 vote. Mayor Mamdani signed it on November 10, 2026; the law takes effect one year after signing. COPA gives qualified nonprofits and community land trusts a first window to purchase eligible residential buildings before they reach the open market. Brick Underground reports that, in the long term, renters whose buildings are sold could end up in affordable apartments or owning them through co-op conversions. The bill itself mentions co-op conversion only in an exclusion, §26-863(h). If a conversion happens under the Business Corporation Law, the sponsor may have to fund a reserve under NYC Administrative Code § 26-703, where that chapter applies: a fund set up within 30 days after closing, with supplemental contributions as the sponsor sells its remaining shares over up to five years. After that, we found no New York statute setting a reserve percentage. Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 says directors "shall periodically set aside reasonable sums for reserves," with no amount, and whether it reaches co-ops formed under the Business Corporation Law is unsettled as far as we can tell. New co-op shareholders would also find no license specific to managing agents and no administrative enforcement forum for owners who find their board unresponsive.
Update, November 13, 2026: COPA is law. The same day, a distressed East Harlem portfolio went to a foreclosure auction the law does not cover.
Mayor Mamdani signed Intro 905-A on November 10, 2026. It is Local Law 164 of 2026, and it takes effect one year after it became law (Council legislative record, amNY). This article originally said the mayor was expected to sign it; the opening paragraph has been updated.
The same day, lenders began auctioning the former Emerald Equities portfolio in East Harlem: 38 buildings with about 850 mostly rent-stabilized apartments and roughly $250 million in mortgage loans, sold building by building over three auction days (Gothamist). The administration had backed a bid by the developer Spatial Equity. Gothamist reported that the lenders rejected its first offer of $68 million, as City Limits reported in July, and, according to a co-founder of the East Harlem Tenant Union, a $110 million offer in October. Tenants had hoped to bring five buildings on East 103rd Street into a community land trust, which Gothamist describes as nonprofit ownership that gives tenant groups power over housing decisions or allows residents to buy their units at permanently affordable rates.
The New York Post reported that at the auction on Tuesday, November 10, 14 of 15 buildings "failed to attract outside buyers, with most reverting to plaintiff US Bank National Association for nominal bids of $500 apiece," and that 417 East 114th Street sold for $826,000. The Post also reported that the buildings had more than 2,300 housing code violations when the city became involved. Another group is scheduled for auction on November 17.
COPA would not have reached these sales even if it were already in effect. Section 26-863 says the chapter does not apply "[t]o any transfer of real property effected by (1) a government entity implementing its powers of eminent domain, (2) a judicial proceeding, including a judicially supervised sale, (3) a bankruptcy proceeding, or (4) other operation of law," or to a transfer "made under a deed in lieu of foreclosure or related agreement related to the repayment of a loan and avoidance of foreclosure."
Distress is also one of the ways a building comes under the law. Under Section 26-852, a building with four or more apartments is covered if, among other criteria, it "[p]articipates in the alternative enforcement program," for at least a year, "[h]as a violation annual daily average equal to or greater than 3," or "[h]as been determined by the commissioner, pursuant to section 11-401.1, to be a distressed property subject to an in rem foreclosure action." As we read the text, the buildings most likely to qualify through distress are also among the most likely to change hands through a foreclosure sale or a deed in lieu, which the law excludes, though its definition of a sale does include a lender-approved transfer for less than the owner's debt. That is our reading, not a finding about how HPD will apply it; HPD has the coming year to set the program up and certify nonprofits (amNY).
This matters for the question this article asks. The tenants' goal was a land trust with a path to resident ownership. Whatever owner the East Harlem buildings end up with will inherit their repair backlog. In our view, a building that reaches resident ownership carrying that backlog is where the gaps below matter most: no reserve requirement we could find, no license specific to managing agents, and no forum short of court.
What COPA does and where co-op conversion fits.
Under Intro 905, a qualified housing organization has 20 days to file a statement of interest when an eligible building goes to market, then 70 days to submit a purchase offer before the seller can complete a sale to anyone else. Council Speaker Julie Menin said the bill initially applied to 10,000 buildings and that 2,100 now meet its revised criteria. HPD's revised estimate is 3,400 buildings. Former Mayor Adams vetoed an earlier version in 2025.
COPA's immediate effect is to give certified nonprofits and joint ventures a first opportunity to buy covered buildings. In 2025 testimony to the City Council, the East New York Community Land Trust said it had acquired a multifamily building to convert and that after rehabilitation all of its tenants will become co-op shareholders. If the co-op is formed under the Business Corporation Law alone, its shareholders will own their apartments with the gaps described below.
What BCL gives new co-op shareholders.
New York's Business Corporation Law governs co-op corporations formed under it. Under BCL §624, a shareholder may examine the minutes of shareholder proceedings and the record of shareholders "upon at least five days' written demand," and may request an annual balance sheet and profit and loss statement. BCL §626 creates a derivative suit framework, so a shareholder can sue on the corporation's behalf when the board will not act. Those two mechanisms are real.
BCL stops there. We found no reserve fund requirement in it. It does not require the board to obtain an annual audit or share one with shareholders. It does not require the managing agent to hold any license, pass any exam, or carry any fidelity bond. Courts review a co-op board's decisions under the standard the Court of Appeals set in Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp., by analogy to the business judgment rule, under which courts will not substitute their judgment for the board's so long as it acts for the purposes of the cooperative, within its authority and in good faith, and the shareholder carries the burden of showing otherwise. We found no state agency that hears co-op governance complaints administratively; the Attorney General can sue to remove a director for cause (BCL § 706(d)). We found no ombudsman. S7745, which would have created a Cooperative and Condominium Ombudsperson Program within DHCR, did not advance before the session concluded June 5, 2026.
The AG's conversion rules end at the closing table.
When a COPA-acquired building converts to a co-op, the AG's Real Estate Finance Bureau oversees the offering plan under the Martin Act (General Business Law Article 23-A). Effective September 16, 2026, the REFB adopted amendments to 13 NYCRR Parts 18 and 23 covering offering plans for the conversion of occupied rental properties in New York City, reflecting the 2019 and 2022 amendments to GBL §352-eeee.
Those rules end at the closing table. The Martin Act regulates the offering; we found no REFB authority over post-closing board governance, such as how the board funds reserves, who manages the building, and how shareholders challenge a board that misappropriates funds.
What the HDFC record shows.
New York already has affordable co-op homeownership at scale. As of 2025, more than 1,000 HDFC co-ops were in HPD's portfolio. The NY Attorney General and HPD launched a $750,000 pilot in 2025 to assist approximately 20 to 30 of them. The AG's release says most HDFC co-ops are financially stable, that a review found a high number at high risk, and that these issues often point to a need for structural support that could include governance issues, shareholder engagement, and legal matters.
HPD's own co-op conversion program shows what a regulated path can look like. Its Affordable Neighborhood Cooperative Program term sheet, for rehabilitated city-owned buildings, says ownership "will subsequently be conveyed to a newly formed, resident-controlled cooperative HDFC," under a regulatory agreement that requires capitalized operating reserves, "A minimum $300 per unit repair and replacement reserve," third-party property management and a co-op monitor for the regulatory period, and annual audited financial reports. We found nothing in COPA that says which form a co-op conversion after a COPA sale would take. The gaps this article describes apply to a co-op formed under the Business Corporation Law alone, or once a regulatory agreement's requirements end. Under Private Housing Finance Law §573, an HDFC is incorporated under Article XI of that law together with the Business Corporation Law or the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law, and §576 gives the supervising agency powers including consent to a disposition of property and, in specified circumstances, appointment of a board majority. A co-op formed under the Business Corporation Law alone has neither. COPA does not change BCL. It does not establish a reserve requirement. It does not create a license for the managing agents those buildings could hire.
The managing agent question COPA does not answer.
S.71, the managing agent registration bill, will need a new Senate sponsor in the 2027 session, because its sponsor, Senator Kavanagh, announced he would not seek re-election. Under the bill's 2025-2026 text, property managers of co-ops and condos statewide would file a registration statement with the Secretary of State and obtain a certificate; managers whose portfolios total fewer than 25 residential units are exempt. S.71 has been introduced in nine consecutive sessions, and the 2026 session concluded June 5 with the bill in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Any co-op created through a conversion after a COPA sale could hire a managing agent who needs no license specific to the job. COPA adds no administrative framework for what happens after an offering plan is accepted.
| Protection | Required by BCL for co-ops | Changed by Intro 905-A | NY statute |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reserve fund | No | No | None found in BCL; Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 asks for "reasonable sums," reach over BCL co-ops unsettled; Admin. Code § 26-703 sponsor-funded reserve at conversion; reserve study bills not enacted |
| Annual audit | No | No | BCL §624 gives inspection rights; no audit mandate |
| Licensed managing agent | No | No | S.71 not enacted; we found no license specific to managing agents |
| Fidelity bond | No | No | No BCL requirement in the sections reviewed |
| Enforcement forum | No (courts only) | No | S7745 ombudsperson bill not enacted |
| Derivative suit right | Yes | No | BCL §626 |
| Records access | Yes, limited | No | BCL §624(b): minutes of shareholder proceedings and record of shareholders, on five days' written demand; §624(e): annual balance sheet and profit and loss statement on request |
Bottom line.
In our view, COPA is an anti-displacement tool, not a governance tool, and the bill's sponsors are not responsible for the governance gaps in New York law. But the gap matters if COPA sales lead to resident ownership. Ownership is durable only when the owners have a workable framework to govern their own building, in our view. COPA does not change that framework. The bills that would change it (S.71, S7745, and the reserve study bills A8945 and S7600) did not pass both houses before the session concluded June 5, 2026. Any co-op that emerges from a COPA sale under BCL will carry that absence forward.
Correction: An earlier version of this article misattributed a building estimate to HPD, quoted words not in the Attorney General's release, gave an unsourced HDFC distress figure, misstated S.71 and the session's end date, and said flatly that BCL co-ops have no statutory reserve requirement. It also said Levandusky bars a challenge absent fraud or self-dealing, when the decision also allows review of action that has no legitimate relationship to the cooperative's welfare, singles out individuals, ignores the relevant facts or exceeds the board's authority. The article was corrected on November 4 and 5, 2026.
Correction, November 15, 2026: An earlier version said co-ops from COPA would have no "licensed agent," called the Admin. Code § 26-703 reserve a one-time deposit, overstated BCL § 624 inspection rights and compared them with condo owners' rights, said the Condominium Act has no counterpart to the BCL derivative suit, presented the Levandusky standard as part of the BCL, said the AG lacks authority over co-op governance because of RPL Article 9-B and that no state agency takes co-op governance complaints, said an AG memorandum on senior and disabled tenants was issued with the September 2026 rules, and described S.71 as covering only New York City. It also misstated the New York Post's account of the November 10 auction and omitted that COPA's definition of a sale includes a lender-approved transfer for less than the owner's debt and that HPD's own co-op conversion program requires reserves, third-party management, a monitor and audited reports during its regulatory period.
Primary sources: NYC Council Int 0905-2026 (COPA) · NY Business Corporation Law §624 · §626 · §706 · S.71 (2025-2026) bill text · S7745 · S7600 · A8945 · Martin Act, GBL Article 23-A · Cooperative Corporations Law § 72 · NYC Admin. Code § 26-703 (unofficial copy) · AG Real Estate Finance Bureau, recent rulemaking · Private Housing Finance Law §573 · §576 · HPD ANCP term sheet · Levandusky v One Fifth Ave. Apt. Corp., 75 NY2d 530 (1990) · East New York CLT testimony (May 14, 2025) · LeadingAge NY, close of the 2026 session · AG/HPD HDFC pilot program (2025) · Brick Underground, Oct. 22, 2026 · amNY, Nov. 10, 2026 · Gothamist, Nov. 10, 2026 · New York Post, Nov. 12, 2026
Companion resources: Why the NY AG's Real Estate Finance Bureau can't resolve most condo governance disputes. · New York plans 300 new affordable co-op units by 2028. We found little state law on reserves or managers. · New York is planning 50,000 homes on city land. Its HDFC co-ops show what ownership can need later. · The senator who carried New York's managing-agent bill is leaving. We found no announced successor for 2027. · Regulatory gap index