← BLOG

NYC will pay $60M for 64 properties it took, 30 of them HDFC buildings. We found no shareholder protection in the BCL.

Judge Jennifer L. Rochon of the Southern District of New York certified the settlement class in McConnell Dorce v. City of New York last week. New York's Business Corporation Law contains no provision that would have stopped any of it. Companion to NYC will fund 300 affordable co-ops. Same governance gap.

In October 2026, Judge Jennifer L. Rochon of the Southern District of New York certified the settlement class and granted preliminary approval to a $60 million settlement in McConnell Dorce et al. v. City of New York et al. The settlement covers 64 properties containing approximately 839 housing units, including 30 housing development fund corporation buildings, whose deeds the city transferred in 2018 under the Third-Party Transfer program. New York's Business Corporation Law governs co-op corporations incorporated under it, and the sections reviewed below do not protect shareholders from that outcome. A final approval hearing is set for May 5, 2027. Mayor Zohran Mamdani's housing plan backs a City Council bill that would revive and overhaul the TPT program.

What the Third-Party Transfer program did.

New York City's Third-Party Transfer program operated under NYC Administrative Code §11-412.1. Properties with delinquent municipal charges could pass through foreclosure to a nonprofit intermediary, Neighborhood Restore Housing Development Fund Corp., and eventually to developers selected to rehabilitate and manage them as affordable housing. Created in 1996, the program offered an alternative to the city taking ownership and managing deteriorating buildings itself. It ran ten rounds, the last in 2018, and the city suspended it in 2019. A 2019 City Council investigation found that half of the 420 properties initially selected for Round 10 did not qualify as distressed under the law.

In Round 10, the city transferred deeds for 64 properties in 2018. Thirty were owned by housing development fund corporations. Under Private Housing Finance Law §573, an HDFC is incorporated under Article XI of that law together with the Business Corporation Law or the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law. In an HDFC co-op, residents hold shares tied to their apartments. When the deed transferred, the corporation no longer held title. Former co-op owners in a Bronx building told ABC7 that they became renters with little to no notice and without being paid.

What BCL says about shareholder equity, and where it stops.

The Business Corporation Law governs co-op shareholders through Articles 5, 6, 7, and 10. Section 501 addresses authorized shares and share classes. Section 624 gives shareholders the right to inspect corporate books and records. Section 706 provides procedures for removing directors at a shareholder vote. Article 10 governs voluntary dissolution and requires a shareholder vote to dissolve. None of those sections address what happens to shareholders when the corporation loses its real property deed in a government proceeding that did not require a shareholder vote or offer shareholders a purchase right.

BCL provision What it gives co-op shareholders What Round 10 TPT bypassed
§501: Shares Authorized shares and share classes of the corporation Shares remained; the deed transferred to a third party without a shareholder vote
§624: Inspection Right to inspect corporate books and records New deed holder had no obligation to the prior corporation's shareholders
§706: Directors Shareholders may remove directors Board authority over the building ended when the corporation lost title
§1001: Dissolution Shareholder vote required to authorize dissolution No dissolution occurred; the corporation persisted without its asset

What the settlement covers, and what it does not.

The $60 million settlement, if it receives final approval at the May 5, 2027 hearing, will compensate former owners of the 64 Round 10 properties, including co-op shareholders. Judge Rochon appointed Cecelia Jones as settlement class representative. According to Law360, Jones alleged that the transfer of her Crown Heights, Brooklyn, cooperative building wiped out her shares' value and made her a renter in her own home without compensation. Former owners may submit claims under the notices Judge Rochon authorized.

The settlement does not cover owners from the nine earlier rounds of the program. Those claims remain pending in federal court. The city denies that the Round 10 transfers violated the former owners' rights and has not admitted liability. Settlement is a payment to resolve litigation risk. The underlying gap in BCL is unchanged.

What the nine earlier rounds mean for the statute.

The nine earlier rounds of the TPT program covered roughly 500 properties. According to Law360, the city argues those claims are time-barred, and the plaintiffs have moved to certify a class covering those owners. The plaintiffs' position draws on Tyler v. Hennepin County, in which the U.S. Supreme Court held in 2023 that keeping property value beyond the amount owed in taxes violated the Fifth Amendment. A settlement, as in Round 10, does not produce a ruling on that question in this case.

Mamdani plans to revive the program.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani's "Block by Block" housing plan, released May 26, 2026, backs Council member Pierina Sanchez's SAFER Homes Act, which would revive and overhaul the program. According to The Real Deal, the bill changes how buildings are selected, creates new owner exemptions, allows owners to recoup proceeds above unpaid taxes and interest if their property is sold, and eliminates the block pickup provision. An HPD spokesperson said the administration and the City Council are working to "update and strengthen" the program. None of those descriptions mentions an amendment to BCL.

If a revived program runs additional rounds in buildings with co-op shareholders and produces comparable litigation, the city could face similar exposure. The McConnell Dorce plaintiffs challenged the city's failure to compensate owners for surplus equity, the value of their properties beyond outstanding municipal liens. That is a takings claim available to owners generally. BCL does not address the question for co-op shareholders, and the settlement does not change BCL.

What the HDFC universe looks like today.

New York City's housing development fund corporation co-ops are a subset of the 4,226 co-op buildings in CCNYC's 15,108-building dataset, built from NYC PLUTO and public tax records. HPD's active HDFC portfolio includes more than 1,000 buildings. The New York State Attorney General's office said in 2025 that a review found a high number of them at high risk, while most are financially stable. The May 2026 housing plan includes "Our Home," $75 million in loans to help roughly 300 renters buy and convert their buildings into co-ops. CCNYC covered the governance rules those buildings would face in September.

The BCL sections reviewed above do not give a co-op shareholder a right that survives a government deed transfer made without a shareholder vote. HDFC buildings were in Round 10, and if the TPT program returns, they could be again.

Bottom line.

Judge Rochon's preliminary approval of the $60 million settlement in McConnell Dorce is a remedy for about 839 homes in 64 properties, 30 of them HDFC buildings, from a single round of a program the city halted and now plans to restart. The BCL sections reviewed above do not protect co-op shareholders from a government proceeding that transfers their building's deed without a shareholder vote. The settlement resolves surplus-equity claims and leaves BCL unchanged. Whatever the SAFER Homes Act changes in the program, BCL as written would give future HDFC shareholders no new protection.

Primary sources: The Real Deal, Oct. 28, 2026 · Bloomberg Tax · Law360: Judge Advances $60M Deal Over NYC Foreclosure Program · ABC7 New York investigation · The Real Deal, May 26, 2026 · AG/HPD HDFC pilot program (2025) · Private Housing Finance Law §573 · NYC Administrative Code §11-412.1 · NY Business Corporation Law §§501, 624, 706, 1001

Companion resources: NYC will fund 300 affordable co-ops. Same governance gap. · New York has $22B to build affordable homes and $750,000 to save the ones it already built · NYC passed COPA. Co-ops that emerge from it would have no ongoing reserve floor or licensed agent. · Why the AG can't help with condo governance disputes · Regulatory gap inventory